Ecology and SocietyEcology and Society
 E&S Home > Vol. 27, No. 1 > Art. 42
The following is the established format for referencing this article:
Ralaingita, M. I., G. Ennis, J. Russell-Smith, K. Sangha, and T. Razanakoto. 2022. The Kere of Madagascar: a qualitative exploration of community experiences and perspectives. Ecology and Society 27(1):42.
https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-12975-270142
Research

The Kere of Madagascar: a qualitative exploration of community experiences and perspectives

1College of Health and Human Sciences, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia, 2College of Health and Human Science, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia, 3Darwin Centre for Bushfire Research, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia, 4College of Engineering, IT & Environment, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia, 5CERED, University of Antananarivo, Antananarivo, Madagascar

ABSTRACT

The Kere is a recurrent famine occurring in the south of Madagascar that emerged substantively in the 1930s. Each major event claims thousands of lives and keeps many in a cycle of impoverishment, despite the existence of various aid-based responses. This assessment presents qualitative research exploring two Kere-affected communities’ experiences of the phenomenon. Through focus group discussions, we learn that the Kere is a complex social-ecological disaster, compounded by an intricate chain of causation and impacts. Seeking a deep understanding of affected peoples’ perceptions and experience of the phenomenon, this paper challenges the idea that the Kere is a famine caused by recurring drought that can only be solved with provision of water and aid-based solutions. Based on community views and research literature, and the application of Ostrom’s social-ecological systems framework, we demonstrate that the Kere is a phenomenon compounded by multiple interacting, debilitating factors including deforestation, drought, pests and diseases, food insecurity, extreme poverty, lawlessness, and political malaise; thus, solutions require a comprehensive, sustained, holistic response.
Key words: famine; Kere of Madagascar; pastoralists; qualitative research; social-ecological disaster;

INTRODUCTION

The Kere[1] is a recurrent catastrophic starvation phenomenon[2] that occurs in the southern semiarid and arid parts of Madagascar called the “Deep South”[3]. It claims thousands of lives per year and keeps the subregion in a cycle of poverty. Affecting an area of about 50,000 km² stretching from the Onilahy River in the north to the Mandrare River in the south, it covers two regions, the Androy and the Atsimo-Andrefana. Although it has been the focus of relief-aid interventions for decades, Kere events persist. In the Kere-prone zone, 97% of the population are classified “very poor” (INSTAT 2014) while 67.5% are in continuous undernourishment[4] (Razanakoto 2017).

In recent decades no year has passed without a Kere event in the Deep South. However, aside from media broadcasts depicting horrifying images of starved individuals and humanitarian-driven reports of casualties, few know exactly what the Kere is. Research about the Kere is scarce and no holistic view of the phenomenon has been formed. Government documents do not use the term Kere or “famine,” instead, they refer to “drought and food insecurity.” The recent Drought Recovery and Resilience Plan refers to drought induced by El Niño, aggravated by a high vulnerability to natural hazards (PRR BNGRC-PNUD 2016). The National Contingency Plan for Nutritional and Food Insecurity in the Grand-South refers to the phenomenon as a drought-related food insecurity (NCP-NFI BNGRC IASC 2015). Similarly, the National Desertification Action Plan 2008-2018 refers to it as a poverty-driven desertification (Madagascar Gouvernement 2008).

The study described in this paper explores the Kere as a lived experience. We seek to build a comprehensive understanding of the Kere, how it develops, persists, and impacts communities. In so doing, we aim to highlight affected communities’ views of the Kere phenomenon and explore their ideas about why it is so resistant to decades of aid interventions. Essentially, this approach moves away from the conventional understanding of the Kere as a famine induced by droughts. Instead, we adopt a social-ecological systems perspective that contextualizes the Kere within the complex system made of humans and nature that constitutes the Deep South (Ostrom et al. 2007). This systemic view allows not only the in-depth exploration of the root causes of the phenomenon, but also a holistic understanding of dynamics between the o’ndaty (tribal members and natives of the Deep South) and their natural system (Petrosillo et al. 2015).

Social-ecological systems (SESs) are complex open systems, made up of many interacting parts of coupled social and ecological systems. According to Mitchell (2006) and Siegenfeld and Bar-Yam (2020), the individual parts of the system interact in a chaotic way to engender behavioral changes in the whole system that are difficult to understand by studying the individual parts in isolation. These collective effects, known as “emergent behaviors,” are episodic and self-organized, and may engender catastrophic behavior especially when the system undergoes perturbation (Hayes and Andrews 2020). Embracing the SES perspective, this qualitative study is a deep inquiry into the Kere to holistically unpack the underlying factors that contribute to its formation and recurrence.

BACKGROUND

In 1923, pressured to complete the annexation of Madagascar, the French colonial administration decided to eradicate the raketa (cacti: Opuntia ficus-indica, O. tomentose, O. robusta, O. monacantha, and O. vulgaris [Decary 1929]) vegetation of the Deep South with an introduced beetle parasite (Kaufmann 2001). Prior to that, the Deep South was densely vegetated by thorny bushes dominated by raketa plants that provided an effective food source and served as a barrier to colonial military control (Decary 1929, Kaufmann 2000, 2001). Tribal anti-colonial fighters, referred to by participants in this study as the Sadiavahe (“loincloth made from wood-root”), utilized the protection afforded by the raketa to resist the French colonial forces for over two decades (Pearson 1997, Middleton 1999, Kaufmann 2001). In November 1924, the French introduced canisters of biologically manipulated cochineal beetles (Dactylopius coccus) into healthy raketa thickets in the region of Tsongobory (Allorge and Matile-Ferrero 2011). The parasite decimated the plants at a rate of ~100 km per year (Kaufmann 2000). By the end of April 1929, an official report of the “death of the raketa” was sent to the colonial governor (Kaufmann 2000). In the same year, the growing number of dead animals and a looming great famine was reported in the journal, Echo du Sud (Kaufmann 2000, 2001). The result of the raketa war of 1924–1929 was the onset of the first great famine, commencing in 1930 and eventually abating by 1933 (Middleton 1999). This first Kere claimed an estimated half a million lives (Decary 1947), numbers that Middleton (1999) has argued are too conservative. Thenceforth, the Kere has involved a recurring set of catastrophic events.

STUDY SITES

The Kere-prone zone is a tribal territory associated with two pastoralist ethnic groups, namely the Mahafaly and the N’tandroy. The Mahafaly is a tribal group of the Atsimo-Andrefana region that occupies the semiarid territory of the Plateau of Mahafaly (Kaufmann and Tsirahamba 2006). With their capital at Ampanihy, Mahafaly social structure comprises a confederation of hundreds of subgroups called tariha (clans) and karaza (groups), each led by a Hazomanga (Chieftainship or royalty; Eggert 1981). The N’tandroy is the tribal group occupying the southernmost tip of Madagascar, with the capital city of Ambovombe (Fig. 1). Socially conservative, they observe a strict set of traditions (Tsimanova 2015) and function with a complex tribal structure organized around the royal system of the Zafimanara and the Karimbola clans. There are also other ethnic groups that dwell in the Kere prone-zone including the Antanosy and the Bara amongst others (Tsimanova 2015).

People of the Deep South are 94% pastoralists (Razanakoto 2017). They are mostly subsistence peasants and rely heavily on the forest for life sustenance (Tsimanova 2015). The typical occupation of women is homecare and crop growing, while men herd the aombe (zebu cattle, Bos indicus). This animal is highly significant in local culture, as a symbol of social status and a fundamental form of wealth; in fact, it functions as the banking system (Kaufmann and Tsirahamba 2006, Klein et al. 2008). In the Deep South, approximately 60% of households own zebu cattle with herds of up to 200 (Kaufmann and Tsirahamba 2006, Klein et al. 2008). The average zebu cattle per household is approximately 17 (Goetter 2016). Raising cattle is undertaken in rudimentary ways; during anjagne (non-Kere periods), pastoralists implement open-herding, moving from grassland to grassland. However, during the Kere, fodder is reduced to raketa leaves.

The geographic distribution of the Kere comprises mostly the semiarid chalcographic lands of the Mahafaly Plateau, specifically the districts of Ampanihy and Betioky in Mahafaly territory (FEWS NET 2017), and the arid crystalline sandy ferruginous land of the districts of Ambovombe, Bekily, Tsihombe, and Beloha of the N’tandroy territory (PRR BNGRC-PNUD 2016). With a temperature range of 22–35 °C and an average rainfall of 400 mm/year, the Kere territory is characterized by vegetation comprising thorny shrubs, and xerophyte and euphorbiaceous thickets interspersed by grassy savannahs (PRR BNGRC-PNUD 2016). Known for being a region of sarodrano (difficult access to water), the Deep South’s five main rivers (Onilahy, Linta, Menarandra, Manambovo, Mandrare) are wadi/endoreic rivers that remain dry except during the rainy season (PRR BNGRC-PNUD 2016). The groundwater table is located at the depth of about 90 meters in the north to 200 meters in the south (JICA 2006). The Deep South where the Kere occurs is the research site presented in Fig. 1 (IPC 2021).

METHODS

A qualitative approach, using focus groups and inductive thematic analysis, was used to answer the question “What are Kere-affected communities’ experiences and perspectives of the Kere phenomenon?” The focus group discussion (FGD) involved engaging people from Kere-impacted backgrounds to discuss their Kere experiences and perceptions (Krueger and Cassey 2009). To gain a more comprehensive picture, purposive and convenience sampling methods were used to ensure the inclusion of heterogenous adult participants from Kere-prone selected communities (Etikan et al. 2016). However, during the fieldwork, large scale military operations were announced in the Deep South with many districts declared no-go zones (with curfews) for security concerns. This caused an accessibility problem, and in consideration of recommendations issued by local officials, i.e. National Bureau of Disaster Management, District Chiefs, the research team had to adjust by reviewing the field work approach. The team decided to convey participants to safer towns and to increase the number of participants by including as many community members as feasible. Accordingly, the FGD for the Region of Atsimo-Adrefana was organized in Ampanihy, and in Ambovombe for the Region of Androy. This accessibility issue meant we were unable to sample Kere stakeholders from across the entire impacted region. However, as much as possible, we have augmented FGD data with other pertinent sources where available.

The selection of participants was done with district chiefs and tribal clans’ chiefs with the assistance of the local BNGRC (National Bureau of Disaster Management). Each fokontany (village) of Kere hot-spot communities was summoned to select one adult individual representative to the FGD. Twenty-four adult participants (including 7 females and 17 males) from nine communities of Ampanihy attended the FGD on 11 September 2019, and 22 adult participants (including 6 females and 16 males) from seven communities of Ambovombe attended on 25 September 2019. Focus groups were semi-structured and facilitated by a local moderator. Discussions were carried out in tribal dialects and discussions were audio-recorded, then transcribed and translated into English for analysis.

The role of the FGD moderator became crucial to maintain group dynamics and coherence of the large number of participants. The moderator must speak the dialects of both tribes, which carries sensitive cultural codes. We hired a local bi-ethnical moderator (of Mahafaly mother and N’tandroy father) who, in addition to being a native speaker of both dialects, has worked in Kere response for decades and was familiar to some participants. This increased participants’ confidence to speak about their experiences and thoughts. Furthermore, we informed participants that they could speak with the researcher or moderator privately at any time to clarify any issues or provide their views in private.

Data were analyzed into themes in response to the research question. This involved coding transcripts using the reflexive method of Braun and Clarke (2006), and theme structuring utilizing the framework of Attride-Stirling (2001). Transcripts were scanned for patterns, commonality, relationship, consistency, contradiction, and inconsistency of meaning. They were then coded using latent-reasoning, which involves a deepened interpretation of what lays beneath the surface.

The first author (MIR) was present at all focus groups and oversaw the translations of audio data. MIR is a native member of the southeastern tribe of Antesaka, and is a fluent speaker of Mahafaly and Antandroy dialects. We acknowledge, however, that there may be some loss of subtle meanings in translation. Local terms are given in italics, with translation where needed throughout this article.

FINDINGS

With a general aim of building a comprehensive understanding of the Kere through the perceptions and experiences of local communities, four central themes emerged from the data: (a) the meaning of the Kere; (b) elements of the Kere; (c) Kere development; and (d) impacts on community. Each of these central themes is explored in detail (Table 1).

The meaning of the Kere

The meaning of the Kere is centered on three themes: the origin and the utilization of the term; the killing of the raketa plants; and the importance of the raketa. The term Kere comes from the Antandroy people’s dialect, meaning “starved to death.” It has been utilized in disaster management (initially by the World Food Program) since 1993 to describe the recurring deadly famine in the Deep South. To Kere survivors, the Kere disaster infers a severe and prolonged lack of food, rain, groundwater, and money, and involves a significant death toll. Participants described the Kere using ideas such as:

Participants tied the Kere to the destruction of the raketa during the early stage of French annexation of Madagascar when anticolonial resistance (the Sadiavahe) utilized the thorny forest as their hide-out. After two decades of guerrilla war, the French Administration annihilated the cactus with a parasite that the Kere community refers to as the pondifoty. The cactus was an inconvenience to the French but very important to the local people. The plant still plays a vital role to the pastoralists, as hane-rano (food-water). The barbed, water-bearing cladodes provide fodder and water to livestock (zebu-cattle, sheep, and goats) during the dry season, and its fruit is eaten by o’ndaty. The plant also provides a defensive living hedge to villages, cowsheds, and croplands, and is used for property demarcation. The following participant quotes show the link between the pondifoty and the destruction of raketa, and the impact of this.

Elements of the Kere

Participants discussed how the Kere encompasses an interlinked set of four factors that construct this voy (disaster): deforestation; lack of government support; plantation pests; and the geo-climatic conditions. They recognized that deforestation has occurred at an unprecedented rate in recent decades and acknowledged their part in this. They discussed the increasing practice of teteke and hatsake (slash and burn, or swidden), and the over-harvesting of forest trees for charcoal and kitay (cooking wood) that has contributed to this. Although participants are aware of the impacts of deforestation, they claimed to have few other choices for income. Consequently, the Deep South is becoming a tane karakay (naked land) which further exacerbates the effects of drought.

Participants claimed to have been ignored by the central government and discussed the insensitive attitude of successive regimes to their plight. Many believe that this attitude triggered the bloody secessionist rebellion in 1972 following a Kere. Some participants claimed to have never received assistance from government agencies other than through health centers. Aid has been provided only through external aid organizations, such as United Nations agencies and NGOs (non-government organizations). Others disputed this and claimed to have benefited from government aid for undernourished infants, free care provided by local health centers, and cash transfers (though difficult to access and insufficient) from the government’s FIAVOTA Project. Nonetheless, this sense of abandonment by the government engenders the feeling of marginalization, demonstrated by the nonexistence of viable development initiatives and lack of basic infrastructure that act as additional supporting drivers of Kere. The mix of views can be seen in the following participant quotes.

Participants expressed distress caused by insect pests on food production and storage. Crops that survive harsh weather conditions are damaged by the swarm of valala (Malagasy migratory locust, Locusta migratoria capito) and armyworms. Armyworms have only recently been found in Madagascar and inflict significant damage to young plants and seeds. The damage to stored crops and seeds due to the kirokiro (weevil) and the Khapra beetle also devastates food supplies and income sources.

Associated geo-climatic impacts were expressed by participants as the saro-drano (lack of water), characteristic of the Deep South. They asserted that the groundwater table can now be found only at between 50 to 90 meters depth, and that average annual rainfall (~400 mm) is poorly distributed across subregions. Communities anticipate up to 80 mm/month average rainfall during the rainy season (December to March), while during the dry season of April to September, there is no rain. However, participants discussed the recent recurrence of a longer dry season that can continue for several years. They refer to this as the asaramaike (the dry rain-season).

The development of the Kere

Participants explained that the development of the Kere occurs gradually, with small changes seen over time. The analysis found five processes that describe its progression: (1) the Kere Early Signs; (2) the Duration; (3) Ancient Vs. Recent Kere; (4) Kere Forms; and (5) the Storyline of the Kere. Kere emits early signs that the community has learned to read in preceding months. Changes in the natural system, e.g., wind, stars, moon, rain, and animals, provide forewarning. For instance, if the regular wind intensifies to become the tsiokatimo (trade wind) with sandy red dust around May or June and lasting for 4–5 months, a severe regional Kere is almost guaranteed to follow.

Some participants asserted that severity of the Kere is contingent upon its duration. However, their opinions about duration varied from six months to three years. Others argued that Kere lasting more than a year have been rare during recent decades, providing the example of a Kere called Baramino (Digging Bar) in 1997, which was felt locally for less than a year. Peoples’ views on the duration of the Kere is impacted by their geographic location as illustrated by the following quotes from participants in Ambovombe:

I am from the South, but I am doing pasturage in the north ... my zebu-cattle are based there.
in the east, we are currently “anjagne” [opposite of the Kere, meaning good or peacetime] ... no Kere because there has been rain for the last two months ... food products are ... abundant.

These statements are indicative of the different manifestation of Kere in two districts of the same region. Although the northern districts are anjagne (in peacetime), the southern districts are in Kere. Participants argued that communities are impacted by Kere one after another but also can be affected simultaneously. Nevertheless, these locations share a relatively similar geomorphology, microclimate, soil and vegetation types, and population features. This results in communities thinking of Kere as a “moving target,” experiencing Kere one month, and anjagne the next.

Each Kere is perceived to differ from another as it has evolved through time. Participants thought the Kere of earlier times were more pronounced than recent events. To them, ancient Kere were pre-1993. The “SOS Sud” Kere of 1993 killed many and triggered mass migrations, prompting the implementation of the first emergency management response and subsequent international aid program. Participants asserted that Kere of recent times have been of modest magnitude and duration, with some attributing this to the presence of emergency response aid that did not exist 25 years ago.

According to Kere survivors, the gradual development of the Kere is exhibited in four stages. The anjagne represents the good time when food and water are abundant. The situation gradually changes as food for animals/livestock becomes scarce but food for humans remains abundant, allowing people to prioritize the saving of animals (Fig. 2, Form 1). Slowly, food for humans becomes scarce but food for livestock is abundant; therefore, livestock become food for people (Fig. 2, Form 2). Then, the situation evolves such that both o’ndaty and livestock are famished, characterizing the deadliest form of the Kere— (Fig. 2, Form 3).

When discussing Kere events over time, participants tended to use Kere names, not dates, e.g., years and months, because of high levels of illiteracy. They referred to the initial Kere as the Marotaolagne (Scattered human skeletons) or the Tsimivositse (Uncircumcised: tribal subgroups stopped circumcising their boys to symbolize this tragedy), which occurred from 1930 to 1933. This was followed by another Marotaolagne around 1945, the Beantane (Many downed) around 1955, the Malalakakanjo (Loose shirts) around 1970, etc. Participants argued that each of these (pre-1993) Kere were of cataclysmic proportion and killed hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people, and caused mass migration and widespread social disruption.

Impacts on community

Direct impacts

Participants identified two devastating and interrelated end-results of the Kere, the fate (death) and haosa (agony). The death comes in four interconnected forms that are hunger, thirst, violence, and illness. During Kere, availability of food is scarce, causing hunger. Participants reported agonizing pain in the abdomen followed by a terrible headache and subsequent collapse. If help does not come at this point, death ensues. One participant expressed that the starved body organs shut down. An empty stomach causes hypoglycemia, exhaustion, and death. To find food, many wander far on foot seeking food to bring home to the family. Often, they do not return, while those who do may find deceased relatives or empty households.

Kere victims are subject to severe dehydration. Some participants reported walking 25 km from homes to search for water. If lucky, water is stored in gorogoro (calabash) or jerrycans and carried home on foot. Pressed by the severity of thirst, some drink seawater and, as one participant stated, “leave the rest to the god.” Illness kills many during Kere. The body is weakened by the prolonged lack of food and water and is prone to illness. It was reported that water-borne diseases inflict most damage because of the consumption and use of dirty water collected from street puddles and boreholes.

The Kere-prone zone was described as a place of violent crime where bandit dahalo (cattle-rustling, bandit, bushrangers) challenge law and order. Although agreeing that violent crime was wrong, some participants tied it to cultural practices where behaviors are commanded by tribal social norms. A community may reject or endorse the practices of dahalo, which can lead to violence, at times resulting in death.

Agony caused by the Kere can be physical, mental, and social. Participants stated that Kere tests the resilience of o’ndaty; that is, the extent to which the mind and body systems can tolerate and recover or collapse from it. Kere communities may experience a quasi-recovery, being narrowly saved from starvation, only to experience it again soon after. This cycle of starvation and brief recovery takes a high toll on mental health and erodes hope and resilience. Many participants discussed disillusionment in the face of the emotional stress caused by so much profound loss.

Social agony inflicted by the Kere touches all aspects of community life. At the peak of the Kere, energy is focused on securing food and water. All other aspects of life grind to a halt. At this stage, participants report a shift in attitudes to one of self-concern and survival of the fittest. One participant shouted, “carry your own shovel” (tribal expression meaning care for your own self), demonstrating the deterioration of the social fabric. Another expressed, “we are human with no pride and dignity.” Others pointed to the increasing numbers of youth cattle-rustlers and sex-workers, demonstrating the impact of Kere on social norms and deviation from customary mores.

Indirect impacts of the Kere

Indirect ramifications of the Kere are twofold: depopulation and unemployment. Weary of the Kere, many depart their homelands in search of a better life elsewhere, resulting in migration of the o’ndaty from homelands. Narratives of mass-migration are not new, and neither are the push factors. Among the core push factors expressed by participants was the never-ending recovery from recurrent crop failures and the deteriorating social order, especially the proliferation of bandit dahalo.

Unemployment is high in the Kere-prone zone. Participants discussed the lack of sustainable developmental projects that could provide a stable living. Livelihoods in the Deep South revolve mostly around livestock, crop growing, and the kinanga (small trading) of farm products. At the peak of the Kere crisis, farming activities cease, halting related employment. During this period, participants discussed being miheake (purposeless), i.e., dependent on Food for Work (FFW) programs of aid agencies. In FFW, selected individuals from a few targeted communities are hired daily to do intensive labor work such as rehabilitation of dirt-roads and tracks, compensated with food-rations. This may be the sole source of employment available and has proven invaluable in saving lives; however, only a few dozen individuals can be hired because of the widespread magnitude of the Kere.

DISCUSSION

This study has revealed a complex set of local understandings and experiences of the interlinked elements that comprise the Kere phenomenon. Participants discussed the origin, constituents, development, and impacts of the Kere. However, they typically referred to specific instances of the Kere using the local name for it and not in reference to a date. To better understand the patterns of the Kere over time, we examined historical references to famine and mapped them to the terms for Kere used by participants. Key Kere events as described by participants completed with literature are summarized in Table 2. The first great famine of 1930 was attributed to the eradication of the raketa plant (Decary 1929, Middleton 1999, Kaufmann 2001). The raketa was not only the dominant vegetation but also a pivotal life support to pastoralist autochthons (Kaufmann 1999, 2001). Thus, its eradication triggered a multifaceted change to social-ecological systems, including decimation of the land cover to become what participants referred to as naked land. Decary (1947) and Middleton (1999) asserted that the first great famine of 1930 reduced the population of the Deep South by half and drove 15% of survivors to migration. During this period, the tribal territories of Mahafaly, Antandroy, and Antanosy were filled with carcasses of dead cactus and piled with the cadavers of both humans and animals (Decary 1947, Kaufmann 2000). This event came to be known as the Marotaolagne or Tsimivositse (Decary 1947, Tsimanova 2015).

Availability of data regarding the death toll is regrettably lacking. According to GFDRR (2011), the five major Kere that occurred between 1980 and 2010 claimed an estimated death toll of one million, and the Santira-Vy Kere of 1983 killed ~230,000 children. Since its genesis in 1930, the Kere has occurred 15 times over 91 years (Table 2). According to participants, each instance has had its own trigger factors (e.g., cochineal beetles, political unrests), and varied impacts (e.g., many deaths, mass-migration). Based on Table 2, the average duration of the Kere is about two years with an average cycle of recurrence of four years. As at 2021, since 1930 the Deep South has endured 30 years (cumulative) of Kere events. While a Kere event kills many (human and animal) and pushes survivors into a vicious cycle of collapse and recovery, the cumulative effects of 30 years of recurrence constitutes a formidable constellation of forces that traps the population in chronic poverty—the well-described condition of poverty traps (Dutta 2015, Ghatak 2015).

The Kere: a social-ecological disaster

The analysis presented here reveals that the Kere is understood by locals as having multiple constituents, e.g., deforestation, government inertia, and geo-climatic conditions, which together induce a chain of causation impacting each other across time and space. According to Belausteguigoitia (GIWA Approach 2004), chains of causation are the way elements of coupled human-natural systems influence one another. For example, deforestation is driven by over-harvesting and unsustainable slash and burn practices as a way of survival. Harsh geo-climatic conditions attributable to lack of rain and groundwater replenishment lead to drought and subsequent crop failures. These factors and their interaction may differ across Kere-prone districts. For instance, violence driven by dahalo bandits is higher in communities with large zebu-cattle populations than those with less (Goetter 2016). Factors also change with time. Levels of drought-induced crop failure may fluctuate or dissipate in accordance with seasonal rainfall. The longer the dry season the more likely severe crop failure will follow, further exacerbating food insecurity.

We suggest that the Kere phenomenon encapsulates what Rechkemmer et al. (2016) has called a social-ecological disaster resulting from disharmonic interaction between humans and the natural system, i.e., overharvesting of natural resources, and compounded by a complex chain of causation between various elements of a system. For a more nuanced analysis of the social-ecological dynamics of the Kere, we turned to the social-ecological (SES) framework developed by Ostrom (2009). The SES framework decomposes the complex system into six key subsystems (Ostrom 2009). They are resource units (RU), resource system (RS), governance system (GS), actors (A), interactions (I), and outcomes (O); all framed by social, economic, and political settings (S) under a constant influence of the related ecosystems (ECO). Each of these subsystems has a nested second tier of variables (53 in the initial version) aimed to capture key features of the first tier six key elements (McGinnis and Ostrom 2014, Rocha et al. 2020). However, this study only looks into variables that are relevant to the Kere as shown in Table 3 and focuses on resource vegetation of the Deep South.

Key features listed in Table 3 can be further summarized as follows. Loss of vegetation is caused by the extensive harvesting of native trees and the tavy (swiddening) by the o’ndaty. Appreciated for being quality hardwood, i.e. fuelwood or timber, the endemic trees of the Deep South are subject to continual harvesting to supply both internal and external demand. Practicing a traditional rain-fed agriculture in arid land, the o’ndaty swidden expansively, the practice of slash and burn agriculture, to access fresh soil nutrients. This practice, coupled with savanna burning to expand livestock grazing, has caused 45% loss of the Deep South vegetation over the last four decades (Rives 2012, Hanish 2015), hence the increase of barren land.

From a governance perspective, two sets of laws and regulations are implemented by the Ministry of Environment through the Gelose program (Community Based Natural Resources Management) and the Madagascar National Parks (MNP). The MNP administers three forest reservations that cover ~49,150 ha in the Deep South (http://www.parcs-madagascar.com/) and the Gelose transfers the management of the natural resources to the local community (Casse 2012). Porous to infraction of all kinds, i.e. logging or mining, these reservation areas suffer from ineffective policies implementation and lack of resources, becoming “paper parks” (Dudley and Stolton 1999) that are legally protected, but receive no management at all. These infractions intensify during major sociopolitical crises that are common in Madagascar.

Although analysis of the SES using Ostrom’s framework (Table 3) establishes robust linkages between loss of vegetation, soil, drought, and the poverty and hunger among locals, community representatives argued that the Kere encompasses more than that. They also consider harsh geo-climatic conditions (natural hazards) responsible for the periodic drought, difficult access to water, and the effects of El Niño. Participants’ views on the duration of rain deficit vary from 6 months to 7 years. They also stressed that wells must be about 50 meters deep to reach the water table. According to JICA (2006), the water-table in the sandy calcareous soil in the north is about 90 meters deep while in the crystalline south it is about 200 meters; this renders finding groundwater a major problem.

The effects of El Niño on the microclimate of the region are manifested through increased weather temperature tailed by a severe and longer dry season (PRR BNGRC-PNUD 2016). The El Niño is a complex interaction of weather factors (sea and land temperatures, the Indian Ocean Dipole oscillation, and the wind parallelism) that shifts every few years (Cane and Zebiak 1985). This weather system suppresses the accumulation of rain in the region to cause a periodic drought (Cane and Zebiak 1985). Furthermore, participants highlighted the distress caused by pest insects on food production and storage (e.g., locust, armyworm, weevil) attributable to the effects of warmer climates. According to Deutsch et al. (2018), climate warming increases the metabolic rate of insect pests to cause crop losses of 10–25% per increased °C of temperature. In sum, the cyclic drought that induces an idiosyncratic quasi-permanent food crisis is the compound effect of the ecosystem dynamic exacerbated by increased inharmonic anthropic activities. According to Scrimshaw (1997), although these natural factors precipitate famine, they rarely constitute the root cause. The Kere-famine begins when other hazardous events, e.g., dahalo raid, strike the already precarious social-ecological system.

The Kere and social insecurity: the causal nexus

Social insecurity is both a cause and consequence of the Kere, especially the impacts of dahalo (cattle rustlers). As a cause, zebu-cattle raids can ruin households triggering a cycle of attack-revenge which results in many deaths and hampers food production. Consequently, depauperized individuals, especially the youth, become easy recruits for professional dahalo (Goetter 2016). According to participants, scores of villages and communes become deserted no-go zones because of insecurity when the Kere unfolds. Cattle rustling has evolved from being a traditional rite to a profession. In many pastoral societies, especially in sub-Saharan Africa where livelihoods are centered on cattle, pastoralists’ cultural songs and dances cherish cattle rustlers’ bravery (Mkuku 2001) whereby raids against each other’s animals are events of common occurrence. In the Deep South, cattle rustling is a traditional practice that has existed well before the pre-colonial era (Ribard 1926) and has evolved into a network of criminals involving high-ranked government officials and elected politicians (Tarabey 2014; D. Myers 2015, unpublished manuscript, https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection/2285). Dahalo raids result in an annual loss of about 30% of national cattle production, posing a pressing threat to the region’s social order (Fauroux 2004). Between 2012 and 2017, ~100 military, ~900 civilians, 3000 dahalo were killed, 2000 dahalo were arrested, and ~30,000 zebu were stolen (D. Ramarlah 2017, blog, https://sites.google.com/site/barademadagascar/societe/zebu/01-vols-de-zebus).

The Kere: a regional health concern

The Kere is an enduring health problem of public concern. It has caused many deaths and those who survive face a variety of health problems including physical (e.g., cachexia, kwashiorkor, stunting), mental (e.g., poor cognitive abilities), and social disorder (e.g., anti-social, self-centered behavior; Scrimshaw 1987, Dugassa 2019). Participants stressed that a continuous state of inanimation results in being prone to illness, mostly from water-borne diseases and malaria. What differentiates the Kere from other famines is its persistence and duration. As a result, survivors are trapped in a state of undernourishment making them highly vulnerable to disease. According to Razanakoto (2017), ~67.5% of the local population is continuously undernourished. They consume an average food intake of ~1700 kCal/day/person (Hänke et al. 2017), way below the SPHERE minimum standard of 2100kCal/day/person (https://handbook.spherestandards.org/en/sphere/#ch007_003). Sen (1981) asserts that most deaths in famines are caused by illnesses. Because of unavailability of data, Sen’s assertion cannot be verified in relation to the Kere. However, phlegmatic undernourished o’ndaty cannot take part in physically demanding agricultural activities, further hampering food production.

The Kere: a poverty trap

As a sociological disaster, Kere poverty traps are driven by poor regional connectedness and lack of innovative capacity (Carpenter and Brock 2008). Four sets of poverty traps contributing to poor regional connectedness and lack of innovative capacity emerged from the data, namely: the lack of road infrastructure; no structural social support; poor access to education; and systemic marginalization. The lack of road infrastructure renders the in/outflow of goods and critical needs, e.g. food, water, and medication, to the Deep South difficult. If these critical needs are available, their prices escalate so that in order to acquire them, especially food, households must monetize productive assets, e.g., land or cattle. Because of the absence of social support, poor households are left with no means to resist the repetitive Kere and lose resilience when their endowments erode (Thomas and Gaspart 2015).

The lack of innovative capacity is sustained by poor access to education, resulting in high levels of illiteracy, a lack of skilled workers, and systematic marginalization. Lack of education is a key poverty trap for rural households in Madagascar (Thomas and Gaspart 2015). Some participants noted that school was not a priority for people with empty stomachs (others disagreed). This mindset alone, coupled with the broken regional school system, can explain the high prevalence of illiteracy (~66%) in the Deep South (Healy 2017). Participants highlighted their marginalization by the central government. Bird et al. (2010) stressed that systematic marginalization poverty traps often entail ethno-political motives to sideline inhabitants living in remote areas. This thesis is supported by Althabe (2000) and Tsimanova (2015), where they describe various ways colonial administrations have institutionalized punishment of rebellious southerners. This policy was pursued (intentionally or not) by successive post-colonial administrations. As a consequence, major innovative problem-based projects, e.g., sea desalinization plants, which could help to address Kere traps, are often announced by the central government but never see the light. This has led to the Kere territory being labelled as a “cemetery of projects” (UNICEF 2011, Hanisch 2015:2).

The Kere: a governance failure

The Kere is a cascading failure of governance. Although successive post-colonial administrative regimes (neo-colonial and Marxist-Leninist) gagged Kere information, successive post-cold war governments have learned to market it (Tsimanova 2015). Little was known about the Kere until the first liberal government of the early 1990s brought the calamity to public attention through a national telethon called SOS-Sud (Ramambazafy 2020). Since SOS Sud, the Kere has received national and international attention whence food security and disaster management policies were established, and relief interventions began to take place. Yet, the Kere persists.

Raikes (1988) and Dodo (2020) reasoned that Sub-Saharan Africa food crises are the outcome of policy failure. These authors attribute the demise to foreign imposed policies, e.g., the World Bank’s structural adjustment programs, that enforce capitalist economic imperatives as foundational requirements for receipt of aid by poor countries. These imperatives include the stoppage of aid grants and subsidies to farmers (Dodo 2020). Application of these prescribed policies has resulted in African farmers’ loss of government supports that subsequently have led to deficit in food production, and the increase of food imports tied with the dependency on foreign aid (Dodo 2020). Typically, food-aid comprises surpluses of subsidized cheap food from developed countries (Raikes 1988). Whatever these policies’ possible benefits, their application by the neopatrimonialist bureaucrats that use public office for private gain is the true cause of the failure (Sandbrook 1986). Famines capture international aid, thus, more Kere famine, more aid.

The Kere has attracted a plethora of aid organizations engaged in a self-absorbing battle of diverse and competing financial interests, resulting in aid-based emergency responses as the dominant solution (Tsimanova 2015, Razanakoto 2017). Often, a small food crisis is announced as a deadly Kere to mobilize international aid. Paradoxically, aid-based solutions to a complex disaster may have immediate effects but fail to address long-term causes and thereby outcomes (Riddell 2014), as was the case of the cataclysmic famine that hit Ethiopia in 1984 (Vestal 1985). International aid is tied to systemic problems including dependency and mismanagement (Arndt et al. 2013, Broberg 2014, Riddell 2014). According to Riddell (2007, 2014) and Arndt et al. (2013), it cultivates dependency to aid while minimally contributing to the rebuilding of recipients’ capacities. Broberg (2014) and Salifu and Abdulai (2018) stress that mismanagement of international relief aid, which involves aid gone astray, embezzlement, and other forms of corruption, may benefit only officials while the needs of the intended beneficiaries remain unmet. The Kere as a major recurrent event is no exception to this. According to Tsimanova (2015), in 2015 alone the Madagascar government received around US$70 million for Kere reduction programs from multilateral donors; yet little has been done to tackle the root cause of the Kere. As such, focus group participants complained about the invisibility of the government in Kere business, as if it has relegated the Kere responsibility to foreign aid agencies. Consequently, participants expressed no surprise that sustainable solutions to the Kere have not been achieved to date.

The Kere: a famine caused by failure of food entitlement?

Famine occurs when many people are starved from not having enough food for an extended period (Scrimshaw 1987). Starvation is a process that leads to famine outcomes (Conley and deWaal 2019). The Kere evolves from food insecurity to famine but the process leading up to its cyclical recurrence begs for a deeper theoretical consideration. Theoretical debates on how food insecurity becomes famine are shaped by two opposing but complementary views (Bush 1996). The first views famine as the ultimate result of food availability decline (FAD) and the second perceives famine as the failure of people’s entitlements to food (FFE). However, key features of the Kere presented by participants included the prolonged lack of food and the money to buy it, which encompass issues of food availability and the inability to purchase it.

The FAD is a Malthusian view that famine occurs when population growth exceeds food supply capacity (Ambirajan 1976, Sen 1976). In this line of thinking, the decline of food supply can be caused by natural, e.g., drought or pest infestations, or man-made disaster, e.g., civil disturbance or transport failure (Mabbs-Zeno 1987, Scrimshaw 1987). The main livelihood of the o’ndaty is animal husbandry centered on zebu-cattle (Feldt 2015, Goetter 2016). Subsistence peasants (Razanakoto 2017) grow only what they consume which accounts for ~21% of their total annual diet (Hänke et al. 2017), with a small portion for sale. Because of this, crop production occupies only ~15% of the total land surface (WWF 2010), which leads to an annual food deficiency of ~79% and permanent shortage of food even during anjagne. When the Kere develops, food supply rapidly decreases from insufficient to none.

Sen’s FFE approach (1981) hypothesizes that famines are not necessarily caused by the absence of food, but instead the inability to acquire food. Based on the market economy, this view postulates that people’s income, goods for barter, ability to grow food, and access to relief “entitles” them to certain amounts of food. When the price of food exceeds peoples’ purchasing ability, entitlement failure occurs caused by the erosion of their endowment, then famine happens (Sen 1981). With the Kere, this holds true to a certain extent. The o’ndaty monetize properties, e.g., livestock and personal belongings, to procure food for as long as food is available. However, when the Kere grows in length and scope, food prices hike while availability declines. Meagre purchasing power, atrocious roads, and insecurity hinder transportation of food supplies from abutting regions. Participants claimed that trouble begins when stored food is finished and there is no more food to buy or to barter. When food reappears at higher prices, people may sell or barter remnant assets to secure as much food as possible, until nothing is left (erosion of endowment). At this point, their only hope is relief food-aid. Thus, the primary cause of Kere-famine is the dearth of food (FAD); FFE only occurs when food prices hike before it disappears as the Kere grows.

In theory, localized food shortfalls can be met by importing food from surplus areas (Hasell and Roser 2013). This depends, however, on the functionality of local markets, and whether trade between anjagne areas with food surplus and Kere areas with food deficit is sustainable. With the effect of demand elasticity, food shortages escalate prices that would entice traders to bring in more food supplies. In the Deep South however, two interconnected parameters contest this theory: a high level of poverty (o’ndaty live with less than US$1.9 per day [Healy 2017]), and lack of roads. Madagascar’s road network is one of the poorest in the world, and national road sections in the Deep South are mostly impassible, trapping the entire region in a state of isolation (FAO 2000). Dirt roads connecting chief districts and major towns, e.g., Ampanihy, Bekily, and Beloha, are oxcart trails crossing the spiny forest and valleys, home to dahalo bandits that present a constant risk to both vehicle damage and road ambush (Healy 2017). If food supplies reach the market, prices hike while traders may not be able to sell them quickly because penniless o’ndaty are highly “hooked” with free food aid. Although oxcart ambulant traders from abutting anjagne areas may, from time to time, bring-in small amounts of food, e.g., water, dried cassavas, or sweet potatoes, these factors render the local market highly unprofitable to traders, thus hindering regional import of food supplies, portraying what Sen (1981:47) called the “trade entitlement failure.” Clearly, lack of usable roads is a major obstacle to food availability, and hence a key driver of the Kere-famine.

The Kere: a by-product of political events

The relationship between famine and political unrest is well established in the literature. According to Maxwell (2013), food crises can be the trigger and consequence of political unrest. Scrimshaw (1987) and Bush (1996) assert that Africa’s famines are mostly caused by political crisis, e.g., the Sudanese famine in the 1980s. The specificity of the Kere lies in its social-ecological features and cyclical recurrence. Scrimshaw (1987) asserted that although natural hazards precipitate famine, they are mostly man-made. Participants noted the occurrence of the Kere in the wake of critical political events. One possible explanation is the absolute centralization of government power in the capital city of Antananarivo, and repeated coups, e.g., coup d’états of 1992, 2002, 2009, 2018. Each coup has engendered a governance vacuum at regional level and a disruption to the already poor public services and social order (World Bank 2013). Kere history (Table 2) validates the claim that every Kere was preceded by a major political event. For instance, the Kere of 1945 was associated with the end of the Vichy War (Fenies 1957), and the Kere of 1993 marked the collapse of the Marxist-Leninist regime, etc. The relationship between famine and political unrest entails intuitive effects (Adams 2013) that are tied to each case; this makes generalization difficult. Even so, this implies that the Kere has been captive to broader political events and imperatives.

The Kere: social repercussion

Social repercussions of the Kere are profound and extensive, with family breakdown a critical threshold, i.e., a critical state when a system becomes very fragile. Family breakdown begins when heads of households depart to ankarama, or perish during the Kere, e.g., thirst, starvation, illness, or dahalo raid. Participants explained that ankarama is a practice whereby adult males migrate far away and send money back home. Razakanoto (2017) stressed that since the initial Kere of 1930, adult males between 18 to 40 years of age were conscripted as part of the colonial SMOTIG (colonial public services) system to work in vanilla and sugarcane plantations in the north of Madagascar. This has become a migration route. According to Droy and Rasolofo (2004), this practice results in a high incidence (~30.5%) of single female heads of household. Analogous to this, similar migration patterns occurred following Ethiopia’s episodic war-famines. From 1960 to 1989, Ethiopia had experienced recurrent war-famine every 5 years with each instance inducing waves of migration of young people: young men migrated to the southern Ethiopian coffee plantations (Mabbs-Zeno 1987), while young women migrated to Ethiopia’s urbanized cities (Berhanu and White 2000). Most migrants however returned home when crises ended, exemplifying a circular migration that characterizes famine induced migration in the horn of Africa. Kere-induced migration however is not circular because, although the Kere is a temporally circular event, the o’ndaty ankarama rarely return home unless culturally obliged, e.g., funerals. During the last decade, pressed by the growing hardship, more males of younger age have also been migrating away while females remained sedentary (Droy and Rasolofo 2004). Acting as a system perturbator, male depopulation furthers the deterioration of o’ndaty nuclear families and their social system at large.

Kere causes orphans. According to participants, relatives often reject orphans for economic burden. In a country that lacks social assistance infrastructure, orphans are frequently left on their own to grow up as beggars, sex workers, illegal loggers, and above all dahalo bandits, heightening lawlessness. Although there is no specific data to assess the link between Kere and orphans, the INSTAT (2010) reports that orphans (single or both parents) constitute ~6.4% of population < 18 age in the Deep South. This rejection is a clear indicator of the deterioration of family kinship during the Kere. Scrimshaw (1987) emphasized that family mutual help is vital at the onset of the famine, but gradually deteriorates as the famine grows. In their work on the psychological effects of famine, Jelliffe and Jelliffe (1992) explain how the survival of the fittest mindset overtakes family bonds, whereby father and son may fight for a loaf of bread. Shoshan (1980) and Scrimshaw (1987) exemplified famine-induced food riots can grow from family dismay to social disturbance and cause large-scale revolts, such as the Egyptian revolt of 1470 and the French revolution of 1789. Correspondingly, the Kere triggered a secessionist revolt of o’ndaty in 1971 (Raison-Jourde and Roy 2010). Because families are the foundation that society is built upon, the higher the number of families affected, the larger the repercussion to the social system.

The Kere forms: social-ecological systems’ regime shifts

As noted previously, participants described four progressively more devastating forms of the Kere. We suggest that these forms are essentially SES regime shifts. SESs are complex adaptive systems that, in order to maintain functionality, must adapt to perturbations by evolving to a new state where it may find some stability (Biggs et al. 2018). When the SES in the Deep South is pushed to a transitional state it can either slow down and recover if perturbation abates (revert to anjagne), or escalate into a new regime if perturbation augments (shift to Form 1, 2, or 3; Scheffer et al. 2001). At the onset, the Kere impacts livestock fodder calling for the o’ndaty to mobilize resources to save their animals—a shift from anjagne regime state to Kere Form 1. As the Kere progresses in time and scope, livestock are saved but resources at hand are depleted while availability of food items diminishes, signaling a system escalation to a new regime: the Kere Form 2. At any time, Kere may abate, e.g., a good rainfall, and the o’ndaty may begin recovery by planting fast growing crops, e.g., sweet potatoes. If the Kere further escalates in time and scope, resilience depletes while vulnerability augments. At this point, food items for both o’ndaty and livestock disappear, indicating a system shift to a catastrophic regime: the Kere Form 3. Notably, discussions with participants revealed that o’ndaty have learned to identify warnings of system saturation (Carpenter et al. 2011) by observing changes in the behavior of the natural environment, e.g., moon, wind, and stars. This systemic examination of the Kere forms provides an ideal platform for policy design that can break the cycle of its recurrence.

The Kere: not a single cause

Our analysis, and the perceptions of affected study participants, makes clear that the Kere is both the result and cause of a variety of interacting social-ecological factors. Thus, the understanding that the Kere is caused by lack of water, or any single cause, is simplistic and erroneous. In a public speech on 20 February 2020, the Governor of the Androy Region declared that “... because of the lack of rain ..., Kere looms ...” (http://www.cycloneoi.com/archives-blog/infos-diverses/le-kere-famine-menace-dans-le-sud-de-madagascar-suite-a-la-secheresse.html). Lack of water is an inherent characteristic of the Deep South. It is a common idiosyncratic hazard that causes hardship, but alone does not constitute a Kere. The Kere unfolds only when the socioeconomically crippled community is hit by additional shocks. A hypothetical framework illustrating the interlocking elements of the Kere is presented in Figure 3.

CONCLUSION

This research has explored the experiences and perceptions of Kere-affected communities to develop a comprehensive understanding of the Kere phenomenon. Survivors perceive the Kere as a voy made of multifarious interrelated hazards, including drought, insecurity, and ill-health. Relationships between these hazards involve a dynamic chain of causations with pastoralists being both catalysts and victims. These chains of causation are compounded by increased socioeconomic impacts on the Deep South’s ecological system, exhibiting the characteristic of a social-ecological disaster that is an aggregate of natural (e.g., drought, Tiomena) and anthropogenic hazards (e.g., insecurity). A social-ecological systems framework was mobilized to unpack the range of issues at play, and the means by which they influence one another to generate the Kere.

Under the duress of food crises, people’s overreliance on the ecosystem intensifies despite existing forest protection laws, leading to amplified loss of vegetation, ecosystem degradation, and desertification. Compounded by the effects of extreme geo-climatic oscillation, e.g., El Niño, with associated warmer weather, extended dry-spells, emergence of Tiomena, and crop pest infestations, crop production is diminished resulting in food crises. The hardship breaks family bounds and strains social fabric. Stressed and desperate youth become dahalo, leading to community unrest. Violent cattle raids ruin communities and disrupt regional food production and supply, leaving survivors that are highly undernourished, prone to illnesses, and too feeble to work the land. Governments either ignore the issue or, in recent decades, have abdicated their socio-political responsibilities to the short-term priorities of aid agencies. These causal links between drivers and outcomes, which characterize a social-ecological disaster, makes the Kere a formidable poverty trap.

In sum, the Kere is a wicked problem and its resolution requires a robust holistic approach that includes an examination of Kere-affected communities’ own understandings and experiences of the phenomenon. Such an approach calls for the deployment of a new paradigm whereby governments and aid agencies take heed of community knowledge and experience, invest in social, educational, and physical infrastructure, and support local communities to be more self-reliant and self-sustained.

__________

[1] Different from the Judaism Kere term, which is a traditional Jewish mode of reading the Hebrew Bible.
[2] According to the IPC standards threshold, a catastrophic famine, classified IPC Phase 5, occurs when a jurisdiction has at least 20% of households facing an extreme lack of food, at least 30% of children suffering from acute malnutrition, and two people for every 10,000 per day die from lack of food (https://www.ipcinfo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ipcinfo/docs/IPC_Famine_Factsheet_2020.pdf).
[3] The island of Madagascar is divided into 22 administrative regions, of which three regions, Atsimo-Andrefana, Androy, and Anosy, in the arid and semiarid south, are referred to as the Deep South or the Grand Sud (Healy 2017).
[4] FAO, defines undernourishment as the proportion of the population whose dietary energy consumption is less than a predetermined threshold (http://www.fao.org/3/a-al936e.pdf).

RESPONSES TO THIS ARTICLE

Responses to this article are invited. If accepted for publication, your response will be hyperlinked to the article. To submit a response, follow this link. To read responses already accepted, follow this link.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

This study was organized by MIR and GE. Conception of research tool was initiated by MIR and GE followed by sequence of revisions by JRS, KS, and TR. Fieldwork was carried by MIR in full coordination with GE, TR, JRM, and KS. Data analysis and coding was conducted by MIR under the guidance of GE, JRM, KS, TR. Writing of the manuscript carried out by MIR, GE, JRM, KS, and TR. All authors read, revised, and approved the final manuscript.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

A thankful appreciation to the BNGRC of Madagascar, starting from the Director General, Brigadier General Elack Andriankaja to the sub-office of Ambovombe for the invaluable assistance provided during the field work. A sincere acknowledgement to Ms. Hadija Aboudou for her instrumental assistance during difficult times while conducting the field work. A thankful appreciation to the notables, chief districts, and mayors in Ampanihy and Ambovombe. Special thanks to Mr Leda of the Region Atsimo-Andrefana for making the field work possible. A sincere acknowledgement to Katelyn Rossiter for the social and academic supports.

DATA AVAILABILITY

The data and codes that support the findings of this study are available on request from the corresponding author, MIR. None of the data and codes are publicly available because of the non-disclosure agreement with research participants. Ethical approval for this research study was granted by the Charles Darwin University Human Research Ethics Committee, (CDU-HREC) with reference H19037.

LITERATURE CITED

Adams, C. 2013. Bread and riots: assessing the effect of food security on political stability. Dissertation. Georgetown University, Washington, D.C., USA.

Allorge, L., and D. Matile-Ferrero. 2011. Cactus et cochenilles introduits à Madagascar: mise au point à l’appui des collections historiques du MNHN à Paris. Revue française d’Entomologie 33(1-4):55-64. [online] URL: http://www.ilerouge.org/documents/Allorge%20&%20Matile.pdf

Althabe, G. 2000. Anthropologie politique d’une décolonisation. L’Harmattan, Paris, France.

Ambirajan, S. 1976. Malthusian population theory and Indian famine policy in the nineteenth century. Population Studies 30(1):5-14. https://doi.org/10.1080/00324728.1976.10412717

Arndt, C., S. Jones, and F. Tarp. 2013. Assessing foreign aid’s long-run contribution to growth in development. WIDER Working Paper No. 2013/072. World Institute for Development Economics Research, United Nations University, Helsinki, Finland. [online] URL: https://www.wider.unu.edu/sites/default/files/WP2013-072.pdf

Attride-Stirling, J. 2001. Thematic networks: an analytic tool for qualitative research. Qualitative Research 1(3):385-405. https://doi.org/10.1177/146879410100100307

Belausteguigoitia, J. C. 2004. Causal chain analysis and root causes: the GIWA approach. Ambio 33(1-2):7-12. https://doi.org/10.1579/0044-7447-33.1.7

Berhanu, B., and M. White. 2000. War, famine, and female migration in Ethiopia, 1960-1989. Economic Development and Cultural Change 49(1):91-113. https://doi.org/10.1086/452492

Bidou, J., and I. Droy. 2007. Pauvreté et vulnérabilité alimentaire dans le Sud de Madagascar: les apports d’une approche diachronique sur un panel de ménages. Mondes en développement 140(4):45-64. https://doi.org/10.3917/med.140.0045

Biggs, R., G. D. Peterson, and J. C. Rocha. 2018. The regime shifts database: a framework for analyzing regime shifts in social-ecological systems. Ecology and Society 23(3):9. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-10264-230309

Bird, K., K. Higgins, and D. Harris. 2010. Spatial poverty traps: an overview. ODI Working Paper 321. CPRC Working Paper 161. Overseas Development Institute, London, UK. [online] URL: https://odi.org/documents/532/5514.pdf

Braun, V., and V. Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2):77-101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

Broberg, M. 2014. Thou shall not ... misappropriate humanitarian aid: on European Union humanitarian aid and the fight against corruption. Pages 253-271 in A. Zwitter, C. K. Lamont, H.-J. Heintze, J. Herman, editors. Humanitarian action: global, regional and domestic legal responses. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107282100.018

Bush, R. 1996. The politics of food and starvation. Review of African Political Economy 23(68):169-195. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4006247 https://doi.org/10.1080/03056249608704194

Cane, M., and S. Zebiak. 1985. A theory for El Nino and the Southern Oscillation. Science 228(4703):1085-1087. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.228.4703.1085

Carpenter, S. R., and W. A. Brock. 2008. Adaptive capacity and traps. Ecology and Society 13(2):40. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-02716-130240

Carpenter, S. R., J. J. Cole, M. L. Pace, R. Batt, W. A. Brock, T. Cline, J. Coloso, J. R. Hodgson, J. F. Kitchell, D. A. Seekell, L. Smith and B. Weidel. 2011. Early warnings of regime shifts: a whole-ecosystem experiment. Science 332:1079-1082. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1203672

Casse, T. 2012. The international debate on forest management transfer and our contribution. Les Cahiers d’Outre-Mer 257:11-46. URL: https://doi.org/10.4000/com.6477

Casse, T., A. Milhøj, S. Ranaivoson, and J. R. Randriamanarivo. 2004. Causes of deforestation in southwestern Madagascar: what do we know? Forest Policy and Economics 6(1):33-48. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00084-9

Conley, B., and A. de Waal. 2019. The purposes of starvation: historical and contemporary uses. Journal of International Criminal Justice 17(4):699-722. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqz054

Decary, R. 1929. La destruction des cactus par une cochenille à Madagascar, ses conséquences économiques et sociales. Extrait des Annales de la Société linnéenne 8:3-19. [online] URL: https://catalogue.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/cb32002708t

Decary, R. 1947. Époques d’introduction des Opuntias monacantha dans le Sud de Madagascar. Journal d’agriculture traditionnelle et de botanique appliquée 301-302:455-457. https://doi.org/10.3406/jatba.1947.6122

Deutsch, C., J. Tewksbury, M. Tigchelaar, D. S. Battisti, S. C. Merrill, R. B. Huey, and N. L. Rosamond. 2018. Increase in crop losses to insect pests in a warming climate. Science 361:916-919. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aat3466

Dodo, M. K. 2020. Understanding Africa’s food security challenges. Chapter 1 in B. Mahmoud, editor. Food security in Africa. IntechOpen, London, UK. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.91773

Droy, I., and P. Rasolofo. 2004. Les approches de la vulnérabilité alimentaire dans le sud de Madagascar. Groupe d’Economie du Développement de l’Université Montesquieu Bordeaux IV, Documents de travail. [online] URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5178495_Les_approches_de_la_vulnerabilite_alimentaire_dans_le_sud_de_Madagascar

Du Puy, D. J., and J. Moat. 1996. A refined classification of the primary vegetation of Madagascar based on the underlying geology: using GIS to map its distribution and to assess its conservation status. Pages 205-218 in W. R. Lourenço, editor. Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Biogeography de Madagascar, Paris, September 1995. Editions de l’ORSTOM, Paris, France.

Dudley, N., and S. Stolton. 1999. Conversion of paper parks to effective management: developing a target. Report to the WWF-World Bank Alliance from the IUCN/WWF Forest Innovation Project, Gland, Switzerland.

Dugassa, B. 2019. Public health impacts of famine in the Horn of Africa. American Journal of Public Health Research 7(5):171-181.

Dutta, S. 2015. Identifying single or multiple poverty trap: an application to Indian household panel data. Social Indicators Research 120:157-179. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-014-0586-x

Eggert, K. 1981. Who are the Mahafaly? Cultural and social misidentification in southwestern Madagascar. Omaly sy anio: Hier et aujourd’hui (PDF). Vol. 1314:149176. Université de Madagascar, Département d’histoire, Antananarivo, Madagascar. [online] URL: http://madarevues.recherches.gov.mg/IMG/pdf/omaly13-14_13_.pdf

Elmqvist, T., M. Pyykönen, M. Tengo, F. Rakotondrasoa, E. Rabakonandrianina, and C. Radimilahy. 2007. Patterns of loss and regeneration of tropical dry forest in Madagascar: the social institutional context. PLoS ONE 2(5):e402. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000402

Etikan, I., S. Musa, and R. Alkassim. 2016. Comparison of convenience sampling and purposive sampling. American Journal of Theoretical and Applied Statistics 5(1):1-4. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ajtas.20160501.11

Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET). 2017. Madagascar Grand South livelihood zones revision. [online] URL: http://www.fews.net/sites/default/files/documents/reports/Madagascar_Grand_South_Livelihood_Zoning_Revision.pdf

Fauroux, E. 2004. Voleurs de boeufs, État et paysans dans l’ouest et le sud-ouest malgaches. Studia Africana 15:16-45.

Feldt, T. 2015. Interrelatedness of grazing livestock with vegetation parameters and farmers’ livelihoods in the Mahafaly region, southwestern Madagascar. Dissertation. University of Kassel, Witzenhausen, Germany. [online] URL: https://kobra.uni-kassel.de/handle/123456789/2015102749227#

Fenies, J. 1957. Migrations Tandroy. Bulletin de Madagascar [Tananarive] 7(138):923-40.

Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). 2000. Special Report: FAO/WFP Mission to assess the impact of cyclones and drought on the food supply. FAO, Rome, Italy. [online] URL: https://www.preventionweb.net/publication/fao/wfp-mission-assess-impact-cyclones-and-drought-food-supply-situation-madagascar

Ghatak, M. 2015. Theories of poverty traps and anti-poverty policies. World Bank Economic Review 29(1):S77-S105. https://doi.org/10.1093/wber/lhv021

Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery (GFDRR). 2011. Climate risk and adaptation country profile: Madagascar. Vulnerability, risk reduction, and adaptation to climate change. GFDRR, World Bank, Washington D.C., USA. [online] URL: https://www.gfdrr.org/en/publication/climate-risk-and-adaptation-country-profile-madagascar

Goetter, J. F. 2016. The cattle raiders leave us no choice: new transhumance in the Mahafaly Plateau region in Madagascar. Madagascar Conservation & Development 11(1). http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/mcd.v11i1.3

Hanisch, S. 2015. Improving cropping systems of semi-arid southwestern Madagascar under multiple ecological and socio-economic constraints. Dissertation. University of Kassel, Witzenhausen, Germany. [online] URL: https://kobra.uni-kassel.de/handle/123456789/2015070148664

Hänke, H., J. Barkmann, C. Coral, E. Enfors Kaustky, and R. Marggraf. 2017. Social-ecological traps hinder rural development in southwestern Madagascar. Ecology and Society 22(1):42. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-09130-220142

Hasell, J., and M. Roser. 2013. Famines. OurWorldInData.org. [online] URL: https://ourworldindata.org/famines

Hayes, A. M., and L. A. Andrews. 2020. A complex systems approach to the study of change in psychotherapy. BMC Medecine 18:197. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12916-020-01662-2

Healy, T. M. 2017. The Deep South (English). World Bank Group, Washington, D.C., USA. [online] URL: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/587761530803052116/The-Deep-South

Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT). 2010. Madagascar Enquête Démographique de Santé 2008-2009. Ministère de l’Économie et de l’Industrie Antananarivo, Madagascar.

Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT). 2014. ENSOMD, Eliminer l’extrême pauvreté et la faim. Etude Nationale 2012- 2013. Antananarivo, Madagascar.

Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC). 2021. Madagascar: food security and nutrition snapshot. IPC Global Platform, Rome, Italy. [online] URL: http://www.ipcinfo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ipcinfo/docs/IPC_Madagascar_FoodSecurity_NutritionSnapshot_2021July_English.pdf

Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA). 2006. Étude sur l’approvisionnement en eau potable, autonome et durable dans la région du sud de la République de Madagascar: rapport final. JICA and Japan Techno Co., Tokyo, Japan. [online] URL: https://openjicareport.jica.go.jp/pdf/11856531_01.pdf

Jelliffe, D. B., and E. F. Jelliffe. 1992. The impact of famine on the function of the family and society. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics 38(1):2-3. https://doi.org/10.1093/tropej/38.1.2

Kaufmann, J. C. 2000. Forget the numbers: the case of a Madagascar famine. History in Africa 27:143-157. https://doi.org/10.2307/3172111

Kaufmann, J. C. 2001. La Question des Raketa: colonial struggles with prickly pear cactus in southern Madagascar, 1900-1923. Ethnohistory 48(1-2):87-121. https://doi.org/10.1215/00141801-48-1-2-87

Kaufmann, J. C., and S. Tsirahamba. 2006. Forests and thorns: conditions of change affecting Mahafale pastoralists in southwestern Madagascar. Conservation and Society 4(2):231-261.

Klein, J., B. Réau, and M. Edwards. 2008. Zebu landscapes: conservation and cattle in Madagascar. Pages 157-178 in J. C. Kaufmann, editor. Greening the Great Red Island: Madagascar in nature and culture. Africa Institute of South Africa (AISA), Pretoria, South Africa. [online] URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/268445358_Zebu_landscapes_conservation_and_cattle_in_Madagascar

Krueger, R., and M. Cassey. 2009. Focus group: a practical guide for applied research. Fourth edition. SAGE, Thousand Oaks, California, USA.

Mabbs-Zeno, C. C. 1987. Long-term impacts of famine: enduring disasters and opportunities for progress. Staff Report No. AGES870212. International Economics Division, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C., USA. [online] URL: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED282813.pdf

Madagascar Gouvernement. 2008. Madagascar: Plan d’action national sur de lutte contre la désertification alignée au plan cadre stratégique décennal 2008-2018. Antananarivo, Madagascar. [online] URL: https://drmims.sadc.int/sites/default/files/document/2020-03/2008_National%20action%20plan%20to%20combat%20desertification%20aligned%20with%20the%20ten-year%20strategic%20framework%20plan%202008-2018.pdf

Maxwell, D. 2013. Food security and political stability: a humanitarian perspective. Pages 279-301 in C. B. Barret, editor. Food security and sociopolitical stability. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199679362.003.0011

McGinnis, M. D., and E. Ostrom. 2014. Social-ecological system framework: initial changes and continuing challenges. Ecology and Society 19(2):30. http://dx.doi.org/10.5751/ES-06387-190230

Middleton, K. 1999. Who killed ‘Malagasy Cactus’? Science, environment and colonialism in southern Madagascar (1924-1930). Journal of Southern African Studies 25:215-248. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/030570799108678

Mitchell, M. 2006. Complex systems: network thinking. Artificial Intelligence 170(18):1194-1212. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.artint.2006.10.002

Mkuku, K. 2001. Pastoralism and conflict in the Horn of Africa. Saferworld, London, UK. [online] URL: https://www.saferworld.org.uk/resources/publications/75-pastoralism-and-conflict-in-the-horn-of-africa

NCP-NFI BNGRC IASC. 2015. Plan national de contingence: Insécurité alimentaire et nutritionnelle dans le Grand sud 2013-15. Ministry of the Interior, Madagascar. [online] URL: https://www.humanitarianresponse.info/sites/www.humanitarianresponse.info/files/documents/files/madagascar_plan_de_contingence_secheresse_final_-_2013-2015.pdf

Ostrom, E. 2009. A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological systems. Science 325(5939):419-422. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1172133

Ostrom, E., M. A. Janssen, and J. M. Anderies. 2007. Going beyond panaceas. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104(39):15176-15178. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0701886104

Pearson, M. P. 1997. Close encounters of the worst kind: Malagasy resistance and colonial disasters in southern Madagascar. World Archaeology 28(3):393-417. https://doi.org/10.1080/00438243.1997.9980355

Petrosillo, I., R. Aretano, and G. Zurlini. 2015. Socioecological systems. Encyclopedia of Ecology 4:419-425. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-409548-9.09518-X

Plan de Relèvement et de Résilience Bureau National de Gestion de Risques et Catastrophes-Programme des Nations Unies pour le Développement (PRR BNGRC-PNUD). 2016. Plan de relèvement et de résilience pour les districts les plus affectés par la sécheresse déclenchée par El Niño dans le Grand Sud de Madagascar. PNUD Madagascar, Antananarivo, Madagascar. [online] URL: https://www.mg.undp.org/content/madagascar/fr/home/library/crisis_prevention_and_recovery/publication_1.html

Pollini, J., and J. P. Lassoie. 2011. Trapping farmer communities within global environmental regimes: the case of the GELOSE Legislation in Madagascar. Society & Natural Resources 24(8):814-830. https://doi.org/10.1080/08941921003782218

Raikes, P. 1988. Modernising hunger: famine, food surplus & farm policy in the EEC & Africa. Catholic Institute for International Relations in collaboration with J. Currey. Heinemann, London, UK.

Raison-Jourde, F., and G. Roy. 2010. Le soulèvement de la colère. Une répression brutale. Sud 1971. Pages 229-252 in F. Raison-Jourde and G. Roy, editors. Paysans, intellectuels et populisme à Madagascar: De Monja Jaona à Ratsimandrava (1960-1975). Karthala, Paris, France. https://doi.org/10.3917/kart.raiso.2010.01

Ramambazafy, J. 2020. Madagascar. Kéré: la vraie problématique d’un mal qui s’aggrave au fil du temps. Madagate, 7 October. [online] URL: http://madagate.org/madagascar-informations-politiques/a-la-une/7600-madagascar-kere-la-vraie-problematique-dun-mal-qui-saggrave-au-fil-du-temps.html

Razanakoto, G. T. 2017. Analyse de la Vulnérabilités à la sècheresse des Familles Paysannes Tandroy. Dissertation. École Supérieur des Science Agronomique, Université d’Antananarivo, Madagascar.

Rechkemmer, A., A. O'Connor, A. Rai, J. Sparks, P. Mudliar, and J. Shultz. 2016. A complex social-ecological disaster: environmentally induced forced migration. Disaster Health 3(4):112-120. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/21665044.2016.1263519

Ribard, E. 1926. Le vol de bœufs dans le sud-ouest de Madagascar. Bulletin de l’Académie Malgache 9:29-48.

Riddell, R. C. 2007. Does foreign aid really work? Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

Riddell, R. C. 2014. Does foreign aid really work? An updated assessment. Development Policy Centre Discussion Paper 33, Crawford School of Public Policy, The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia. [online] URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2409847

Rives, F. 2012. Gestion des forêts sèches à Madagascar et au Niger. Vulnérabilité et Fonctions des systèmes socio-écologiques pour comprendre les réformes forestières et leurs effets. Economies et finances. AgroParisTech, Paris, France. [online] URL: https://pastel.archives-ouvertes.fr/pastel-00809116

Rocha, K., L. Malmborg, L. Gordon, K. Brauman, and F. DeClerck. 2020. Mapping social-ecological systems archetypes. Environmental Research Letters 15(3):034017. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab666e

Salifu, A., and A. G. Abdulai. 2018. Corruption and international aid. In: A. Farazmand, editor. Global encyclopedia of public administration, public policy, and governance. Springer, Cham, Switzerland. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-20928-9_3368

Sandbrook, R. 1986. The state and economic stagnation in tropical Africa. World Development 14:319-332. https://doi.org/10.1016/0305-750X(86)90072-0

Scheffer, M., S. Carpenter, J. A. Foley, C. Folke, and B. Walker. 2001. Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413:591-596. https://doi.org/10.1038/35098000

Scrimshaw, N. S. 1987. The phenomenon of famine. Annual Review of Nutrition 7:1-22. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.nu.07.070187.000245

Sen, A. 1976. Famines as failures of exchange entitlements. Economic and Political Weekly 11(31/33):1273-1280. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4364836

Sen, A. 1981. Ingredients of famine analysis: availability and entitlements. Quarterly Journal of Economics 96(3):433-464. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1882681 https://doi.org/10.2307/1882681

Shoshan, B. 1980. Grain riots and the “moral economy”: Cairo, 1350-1517. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 10(3):459-478. https://doi.org/10.2307/203188

Siegenfeld, A. F., and Y. Bar-Yam. 2020. An introduction to complex systems science and its applications. Complexity 2020:6105872. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/6105872

Tarabey, B. 2014. Madagascar, dahalo: enquête sur les bandits du Grand Sud. No Comment Éditions, Paris, France.

Thomas, A.-C., and F. Gaspart. 2015. Does poverty trap rural Malagasy households? World Development 67:490-505. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.11.012

Tsimanova, N. P. 2015. Le Kere—terminologie, adaptation, enjeux. Mini-Mémoire de Licence, Parcours : Sciences Sociales, Centre Universitaire Régionale Androy, Université de Toliara, Toliara, Madagascar.

Unicef. 2011. Le sud - cimetière de projets? Document de synthèse preliminaire. Technical report, Unicef, New York, New York, USA.

Vestal, T. 1985. Famine in Ethiopia: crisis of many dimensions. Africa Today 32(4):7-28. [online] URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4186321

World Bank. 2013. Madagascar: measuring the impact of the political crisis. World Bank, Washington, D.C., USA. [online] URL: https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2013/06/05/madagascar-measuring-the-impact-of-the-political-crisis

World Bank Country Environmental Analysis (CEA). 2013. Madagascar country environmental analysis: taking stock and moving forward. World Bank, Washington, D.C., USA. [online] URL: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2013/05/17759163/madagascar-countryenvironmental-analysis-cea-taking-stock-moving-forward https://doi.org/10.1596/33934

World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). 2010. Témoignages de Madagascar: changement climatique et modes de vie ruraux. WWF à Madagascar et dans l’Océan Indien Occidental. [online] URL: http://www.abcg.org/action/document/show?document_id=18

Correspondent author:
Maixent I. Ralaingita
maixent.ralaingita@cdu.edu.au
Jump to top
Table1  | Table2  | Table3  | Figure1  | Figure2  | Figure3