Table 1. Summary of the main characteristics of field-based and genetic methods.
| |
| |
|
Field-based methods |
Genetic methods |
| |
|
Include capture-mark-recapture, radio/satellite
tracking |
Include allele frequency- and genotype-based analyses |
|
Generally provide only a snapshot of processes or events at the time of the
study |
Can infer movement or dispersal over several temporal scales |
|
Limited to animals that can be marked or are large enough and otherwise
appropriate to carry transmitter |
Virtually no limitations on the type of wildlife that can be studied, if
amenable to genetic analysis |
|
Good for examining effect of recently and historically constructed
roads |
With contemporary fine-scale analyses, good for examining effect of
recently constructed roads |
|
Can miss rare or long-range dispersal |
Powerful for detecting rare or long-distance dispersal and sex-biased
dispersal |
|
Low sample size due to low recapture rate, loss of radio-collars, mortality
etc. |
No need to recapture to infer fine-scale and population-level
movement |
|
Generally invasive—capture at least once, usually more often |
Usually at most single capture, or zero captures when non-invasive
techniques are appropriate and feasible |
|
| |
|