Table 1. The core ontological assumptions guiding positivism and subjectivism, adapted from a table in Morgan and Smircich (1980).
| |
| |
|
|
Extreme Subjectivism |
Extreme Positivism |
| |
|
Perspective on reality |
The social world and what passes as “reality” are a projection
of human perception and an act of people’s creative imagination. In its extreme,
there may be nothing outside of oneself: a person’s mind is the world. |
The social world is a concrete, real thing that affects everyone. It can
be thought of as a structure composed of a network of causal relationships
between its essential parts. The social world is as concrete and real as the
natural world. |
|
Perspective on the researcher |
Reality cannot be fully understood, as human processes interpret events in
consciousness before fully understanding its structure or meaning. The
researcher will explicitly state what they believe to be their influence on the
results of the research, taking into account that they cannot be
objective. |
Reality is an objective phenomenon that lends itself to accurate or
inaccurate—depending on variance—observation and measurement. “Any
aspect of the world that is not in some form of observable activity or behavior
must be regarded as being of questionable status”. |
|
Perspective on humans |
Humans use their intuition and experience to make the world into a
meaningful form. Human beings shape the world using their own immediate
experience. |
Human beings behave and respond to stimuli in predictable ways. Although
perception may play some role in response, behavior remains lawful and rule
governed and is a product of the world (and stimuli to which they are exposed).
|
|
| |
|