Table 4. Evaluation criteria for tools grouped into their general capabilities, their use in practice, and the products they generate.
| |
| |
| Tools |
|
Does it enable expression or understanding of uncertainty? |
|
Are the results readily communicable to target groups? |
|
Are the results easily aggregated and summarized? |
|
Are the results clear and appealing to distant/central policy/decision makers? |
|
Does it provide reasonable levels of accuracy? |
|
Does it provide reasonable levels of precision? |
| |
| Bayesian belief network and system dynamic model |
|
Yes |
|
No |
|
Yes |
|
Probably, yes |
|
Yes |
|
Yes |
|
| Discourse-based valuation |
|
Yes |
|
Variable |
|
Yes |
|
Unknown |
|
Yes |
|
Yes |
|
| 4Rs framework |
|
Yes |
|
Variable |
|
No |
|
Yes |
|
Depends on use |
|
Depends on use |
|
| Participatory mapping |
|
No |
|
Yes |
|
No |
|
No |
|
Possible, depends on use |
|
Depends on use |
|
| Pebble Distribution Method |
|
Yes (replication and explanation) |
|
Yes |
|
Yes |
|
Yes |
|
Possible, depends on use |
|
Yes |
|
| Future scenarios |
|
Yes |
|
No, difficult with illiterate stakeholders |
|
No |
|
Unclear |
|
Variable |
|
Depends on use |
|
| Spidergram |
|
Partial |
|
Yes |
|
Sometimes |
|
Unclear |
|
Depends on use |
|
Depends on use |
|
| Venn diagram |
|
Depends on use |
|
Yes |
|
Unknown |
|
Depends on presentation |
|
Depends on use |
|
Depends on use |
|
| Who Counts Matrix |
|
Depends on use |
|
Depends on use and the way in which results are communicated |
|
Unknown |
|
Depends on presentation |
|
Depends on use |
|
Depends on use |
|
| |
|