Table 2. Access and resilience.

   

Case Studies Potter Valley Redwood Valley Santa Rosa Round Valley Tribes
Mechanisms to Access Water
Rights-based Early contractual rights for “abandoned” water ~20 000 ac-ft/yr Extremely limited rights to “surplus” water Contractual rights 29 100 ac-ft/yr Federally reserved water and fishing rights
         
Physical form Gravity-fed irrigation canals Small storage pond
Surface water pumping
Groundwater pumping
Two large reservoirs
Surface water pumping
Unable to physically access their “paper” rights
         
Technology Potter Valley Project Limited SCWA water supply and distribution system Limited
         
Capital Extensive Limited Extensive Limited
         
Markets Sells water Buys water Buys water No market transactions involving water
         
Social networks Strong on a local scale Limited Strong on a regional and state scale Limited
         
Authority Inland Water & Power Commission has the right-to-first-refusal on new water projects in Mendocino County Limited County Board of Supervisors is also the SCWA Board of Directors, ensuring that Santa Rosa interests will be protected Status as a sovereign nation confers access to tribal legal assistance
Potential Resilience
Contingent on its ability to maintain the diversion and/or gain access to other water sources Limited as it has no secure forms of access Robust as it has multiple, extensive, and secure forms of access Contingent on its ability to maintain access to legal resources