Table 2. Access and resilience.
| |
| |
| Case Studies |
Potter Valley |
Redwood Valley |
Santa Rosa |
Round Valley Tribes |
| |
| Mechanisms to
Access Water |
| Rights-based |
Early contractual rights for “abandoned”
water ~20 000 ac-ft/yr |
Extremely limited rights to “surplus”
water |
Contractual rights 29 100
ac-ft/yr |
Federally reserved water and fishing
rights |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Physical form |
Gravity-fed irrigation canals
|
Small storage pond
Surface water pumping
Groundwater pumping |
Two large reservoirs
Surface water
pumping |
Unable to physically access their
“paper” rights |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Technology |
Potter Valley Project |
Limited |
SCWA water supply and distribution
system |
Limited |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Capital |
Extensive |
Limited |
Extensive |
Limited |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Markets |
Sells water |
Buys water |
Buys water |
No market transactions involving
water |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Social networks |
Strong on a local scale |
Limited |
Strong on a regional and state
scale |
Limited |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Authority |
Inland Water & Power Commission
has the right-to-first-refusal on new water projects in Mendocino
County |
Limited |
County Board of Supervisors is
also the SCWA Board of Directors, ensuring that Santa Rosa
interests will be protected |
Status as a sovereign nation confers
access to tribal legal assistance |
| Potential Resilience
|
| |
Contingent on its
ability to maintain the diversion and/or gain access to other
water sources |
Limited as it has no secure
forms of access |
Robust as it has multiple,
extensive, and secure forms of access |
Contingent on its ability
to maintain access to legal resources |
|
| |
|