Ecology and Society Ecology and Society
E&S Home > Vol. 17, Iss. 2 > Art. 1 > Discuss Open Access Publishing 


Model-Based Estimation of Collision Risks of Predatory Birds with Wind Turbines. 2012. Eichhorn, M., K. Johst, R. Seppelt and M. Drechsler

  • Discussion (1 comments)
  • Register

To start or join a discussion you need an account.  You already have an account if you have worked as a reviewer, author, editor, or have previously submitted comments.  Otherwise you need to register (use the register button below).  We do not share your information nor will we start sending you newsletters. To comment click the 'Sign In and Comment' button below.

In some versions of Internet Explorer (eg: 10) you may be required to set the Compatibility View option to submit comments to the discussion form (Go to "Tools" in the menu bar and ensure there is a check beside "compatibility view").

Comments on Eichhorn et al.
Sjoerd Dirksen on Nov 20, 2012 11:11:05

Reading this paper brought up some comments and questions.

In the introduction, it is stated 'Collisions result in high mortality rates, particularly....'. In many cases, collisions do certainly not result in high mortality rates, so why the authors make such a general claim is unclear. I don't think it can be held.

A little further, this claim, and/or the relation of this to raptors, is backed up with references, amongst which Krijgsveld et al. 2009. I was one of her co-authors. We did not find/report a single raptor as collision victim in this study, nor did we claim that collision rates in general lead to high mortality rates.


Ecology and Society. ISSN: 1708-3087